Tax revenue, maybe, but density? This was a hotel, not housing. I for one am not shedding a tear. It would be nice, but certainly not some incredible development toward a sustainable city.So why is everyone so upset about this again? Yes, it would have been an increase in density/ tax revenue.
Dinkytown Hotel - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
-
- IDS Center
- Posts: 4615
- Joined: December 4th, 2012, 11:41 am
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
-
- Capella Tower
- Posts: 2622
- Joined: September 16th, 2012, 4:31 pm
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
It's worth saving if what replaces it is a 3-stall surface parking lot. If someone came forward with a 4-6 story structure that replaced this house and the Library, I wouldn't be concerned with it whatsoever. Again, with all the vacant lots in our city, why is moving these structures not really discussed?I have a 109-year-old house, which is quite a bit younger than the house in question, and I was darn lucky to find a house with the first-floor woodwork intact, mostly original windows and most of the exterior architectural features untouched. If the house in question has original interior detailing I think it's definitely worth saving.
Having a hotel here means people who are already visiting the U (for football, basketball, hockey, visiting their kids, robot shows, etc) no longer need to drive in multiple times to do their business. Does a hotel make for semi-permanent residents the way an apartment building does? No.. but it certainly has benefits to the city (slightly removing congestion, need for daily parking, etc) and the small area (hotel guests will almost exclusively eat out and shop).Tax revenue, maybe, but density? This was a hotel, not housing. I for one am not shedding a tear. It would be nice, but certainly not some incredible development toward a sustainable city.
I'm in 100% agreement that the surface parking lots in Dinkytown should be targeted for development. But I'm not the owner of those parcels, and neither are the City or any preservationists, and we can't really force them to sell, re-configure their layout to face the sidewalk, etc.
- FISHMANPET
- IDS Center
- Posts: 4233
- Joined: June 6th, 2012, 2:19 pm
- Location: Corcoran
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Someone posted in the Save Dinkytown group posted that we don't need hotels on Campus because people will just stay downtown and take the hotel shuttle into Dinkytown and my eyes are rolling so hard at that idea that they've come full circle back to their original position.
-
- IDS Center
- Posts: 4615
- Joined: December 4th, 2012, 11:41 am
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Just to clarify, by "saving," I didn't preclude moving it. I definitely think we can get better use of this particular lot.It's worth saving if what replaces it is a 3-stall surface parking lot. If someone came forward with a 4-6 story structure that replaced this house and the Library, I wouldn't be concerned with it whatsoever. Again, with all the vacant lots in our city, why is moving these structures not really discussed?I have a 109-year-old house, which is quite a bit younger than the house in question, and I was darn lucky to find a house with the first-floor woodwork intact, mostly original windows and most of the exterior architectural features untouched. If the house in question has original interior detailing I think it's definitely worth saving.
-
- IDS Center
- Posts: 4615
- Joined: December 4th, 2012, 11:41 am
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Why? We've not had this hotel before and things seem fine. Where do people stay now? Maybe they stay near the airport, but if so wouldn't the LRT provide a reasonably convenient method to get to Dinkytown?Someone posted in the Save Dinkytown group posted that we don't need hotels on Campus because people will just stay downtown and take the hotel shuttle into Dinkytown and my eyes are rolling so hard at that idea that they've come full circle back to their original position.
I'm not saying a hotel isn't a good idea, just wondering why it's needed *now* as opposed to ten years ago or 10 years from now.
- FISHMANPET
- IDS Center
- Posts: 4233
- Joined: June 6th, 2012, 2:19 pm
- Location: Corcoran
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
If someone wants to stay at the airport they can stay at the airport and spend 45 minutes coming to campus and then leave when they're done with their business. If they want to stay on campus and be on the campus then they need to be on campus. Maybe it has been needed for the past 10 years, I don't know. Right now we've just got the Commons Hotel and the Days Inn farther up University and that's it for campus hotels. Just because nobody's tried to build one until now doesn't mean there isn't demand for one.
There's something to be said for being able to walk out of your hotel and be in the middle of it all, and that doesn't exist in Dinkytown currently.
There's something to be said for being able to walk out of your hotel and be in the middle of it all, and that doesn't exist in Dinkytown currently.
-
- Wells Fargo Center
- Posts: 1331
- Joined: June 8th, 2012, 1:39 pm
- Location: George Floyd Square
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
There's also the former Holiday Inn on West Bank, as well as the University Inn extended stay on 10th Ave & 4th St.Right now we've just got the Commons Hotel and the Days Inn farther up University and that's it for campus hotels.
-
- Stone Arch Bridge
- Posts: 7761
- Joined: June 19th, 2012, 2:04 pm
- Location: NORI: NOrth of RIchfield
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
I hope we see more hotels in neighborhood nodes in our city. People shouldn't be stuck downtown or at a suburban strip hotel. I know a lot of folks who travel to MSP to work on my projects would love to stay at urban hotels outside of downtown. Clearly the market is there for places like Uptown and Dinkytown to get hotels.
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
As somebody who's organized events on campus I can say that the dearth of hotel options is a constant PITA. Between the Commons Hotel and the new Courtyard (old Holiday Inn in Seven Corners) you can usually accommodate most, but further afield you only really add the Days Inn before you're having to put people downtown. The Aloft on Washington has alleviated some of the pressure, but it's still a good ways from campus, too far for most people to consider it walkable. Any hotel within walking distance of the main part of campus would be profitable, I'm sure; the challenge is figuring out where to put one, and hence this problem.
Latest Dinkytown Vote Leaves a Bad Taste in My Mouth
Latest Dinkytown Vote Leaves a Bad Taste in My Mouth
https://streets.mn/2014/02/26/latest-din ... -my-mouth/
https://streets.mn/2014/02/26/latest-din ... -my-mouth/
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Doran could do a similar project while preserving the historic facade (and any developer could add density onto our single story buildings, and commercial districts), it's just not as cost effective or as easy for them to accomplish. SO why not leave our arguably historic, ACTIVELY USED spaces as is until all of our (DUH!) surface lots and easier to develop cost effectively spots first. Then it will become more easy to digest the cost of preservation and creative use of space because there isn't anywhere else to go. Let's have our cake and eat it too. It's not like this is the only place a hotel could go in Dinkytown... in fact it's arguably NOT the best spot for a hotel in Dinkytown, IMO. I hate the argument that new dense urban development and preservation are mutually exclusive, because they aren't when both are valued in a community. I feel like articles like this streets MN article are just polarizing both sides of the argument and not bringing both closer together.
*just some anecdotal articles and imagery.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/12/reale ... .html?_r=0
http://inhabitat.com/nrja-unveils-plans ... -addition/
http://fadedbackpacks.files.wordpress.c ... /1tall.jpg
http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=385610
*just some anecdotal articles and imagery.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/12/reale ... .html?_r=0
http://inhabitat.com/nrja-unveils-plans ... -addition/
http://fadedbackpacks.files.wordpress.c ... /1tall.jpg
http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=385610
-
- Landmark Center
- Posts: 272
- Joined: January 12th, 2013, 1:30 pm
- Location: Jordan, Minneapolis, MN
- Contact:
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Thanks for articulating my feelings exactly. As an urbanist and preservationist I can't understand why these two sides are waging a war.I hate the argument that new dense urban development and preservation are mutually exclusive, because they aren't when both are valued in a community. I feel like articles like this streets MN article are just polarizing both sides of the argument and not bringing both closer together.
Scottie B. Tuska
[email protected]
[email protected]
-
- Capella Tower
- Posts: 2869
- Joined: June 1st, 2012, 9:19 am
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Don't they call this concept (urban redevelopment while preserving the historical character of a building and/or site) "Adaptive Re-Use"?
-
- Capella Tower
- Posts: 2622
- Joined: September 16th, 2012, 4:31 pm
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
http://finance-commerce.com/2014/03/dor ... rejection/
If anyone with a subscription can give a brief rundown, that'd be great..
If anyone with a subscription can give a brief rundown, that'd be great..
-
- Stone Arch Bridge
- Posts: 7761
- Joined: June 19th, 2012, 2:04 pm
- Location: NORI: NOrth of RIchfield
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
My guess is that the reason they aren't suing is because there's a solution in the works (I've heard about it elsewhere).
-
- Nicollet Mall
- Posts: 190
- Joined: December 3rd, 2012, 7:03 pm
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Any details on potential solution?My guess is that the reason they aren't suing is because there's a solution in the works (I've heard about it elsewhere).
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
a 12 storey hotel built next to mesa pizza?
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
I'd like to see a reimagining of the hotel plan that wraps around Mesa, and actually fills in the lot with the house on it. I've got no problems with demolishing an old house, but only if a building is built there, not a parking lot.
Joey Senkyr
[email protected]
[email protected]
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 6393
- Joined: May 31st, 2012, 7:27 pm
- Location: Standish-Ericsson
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Just read the F&C article. Doran says if the study isn't complete in about 4 months, the project is likely dead. He isn't going to sue, but also questions the legality of the Council's decision. No word on any possible solution.
Re: The Graduate - (1300 block of 4th Ave SE)
Honestly, as a grad student who sometimes eats at the restaurants that Doran wants to demolish, I don't really mind the idea of the demolitions themselves.
What I'm really afraid of, though, is that the rents on the ground-floor commercial spaces would be too high for those kinds of smaller restaurants. I don't think the buildings have any particular historic value--the Mesa one, despite being vaguely attractive, is actually kind of dumpy--but the U area really doesn't need another Chipotle, and I sort of suspect that's the only kind of business that would be able to move in.
If Doran could provide guarantees that the same kinds of businesses would really, truly be able to come back to the rebuilt space, I think cool a lot of the community opposition.
What I'm really afraid of, though, is that the rents on the ground-floor commercial spaces would be too high for those kinds of smaller restaurants. I don't think the buildings have any particular historic value--the Mesa one, despite being vaguely attractive, is actually kind of dumpy--but the U area really doesn't need another Chipotle, and I sort of suspect that's the only kind of business that would be able to move in.
If Doran could provide guarantees that the same kinds of businesses would really, truly be able to come back to the rebuilt space, I think cool a lot of the community opposition.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests